October 22, 2025

Is AI Helping or Hurting Student Learning?

Artificial intelligence (AI) has made its way into nearly every corner of our lives—and education is no exception. From ChatGPT and generative AI tools to smart grading software and personalized study apps, AI is transforming how students access information and complete schoolwork. But with these changes come important questions for educators, parents, and communities: Is AI helping or hurting student learning? Are we equipping students with the right skills for success, or making it easier for them to disengage?

At Progressive Learning Academy (PLA), we believe that AI tools can play a supportive role in education—but they must be used with intention, structure, and guidance. Here’s what we’re seeing in virtual classrooms across Canada and how live-instructor-led online learning is helping students stay focused, accountable, and confident.

 
The Pros: How AI Is Supporting Student Learning

There’s no denying the benefits of AI-powered tools when used appropriately:

  • Accessibility: Students can access quick explanations, translations, and summaries to help them better understand material.
  • Efficiency: AI chatbots can help students brainstorm, outline, and edit writing assignments more quickly.
  • Personalization: Some tools adapt to a student’s pace, offering tailored math problems or vocabulary practice.
  • Confidence-Building: Students who are hesitant to ask for help in class may feel more comfortable learning independently with AI.

In theory, these tools align with the goals of personalized learning. They provide just-in-time support, helping students feel more empowered and less stuck.

The Cons: Where AI Can Disrupt or Diminish Learning

But with the good comes the not-so-good. Increasingly, tutors and teachers are seeing students:

  • Rely on AI to complete assignments without understanding the material
  • Struggle with original thinking, analysis, and deeper comprehension
  • Lose motivation to study or practice skills independently
  • Experience academic integrity issues by copying AI-generated content

In fact, some students report that they feel “numb” or unmotivated after using AI too much. Why? Because the effort to figure things out is part of what builds long-term retention and critical thinking skills. When AI shortcuts that process, students miss key steps in cognitive development.

Why Live-Instructor-Led Online Learning Still Matters

At PLA, we continue to invest in live-instructor-led online learning because it offers what AI cannot:

  • Human accountability: A tutor can notice when a student is disengaged and adjust the session in real time.
  • Emotional connection: Relationships with tutors build trust and motivate students to participate and improve.
  • Clarification in context: Tutors can correct misunderstandings, provide alternative explanations, and reinforce learning strategies.
  • Skill-building support: From writing fluency to problem-solving, students get the chance to practice—not just copy.

Our small-group and 1-on-1 sessions are built to promote personalized learning without shortcuts. We support students in learning how to learn—not just how to finish homework quickly.

Skills Training Still Matters

While AI is automating many tasks, the core academic and soft skills students need haven’t changed:

  • Reading comprehension and analysis
  • Writing with voice, structure, and clarity
  • Numeracy and problem-solving
  • Communication and collaboration
  • Focus and time management

These aren’t just school skills—they’re life skills. PLA’s programs combine skills training with compassionate instruction so students can grow both academically and personally.

 
What Parents & Schools Can Do

AI tools are here to stay. But their impact on student learning depends on how they are used:

  • Set clear expectations around when and how students should use AI for homework.
  • Talk about academic honesty and the importance of original thinking.
  • Encourage students to ask for help instead of relying on shortcuts.
  • Partner with a tutor to keep students engaged and on track with their learning goals.
 
How PLA Can Help

Our tutors are already trained to identify when students are struggling with AI overuse. Whether it’s a middle schooler relying too heavily on ChatGPT for essays or a high school student losing confidence in math, we provide structured, live support to rebuild skills and self-belief.

With personalized learning, inclusive learning support, and live-instructor-led online learning, our team helps students stay motivated and build the habits they need to thrive.

Interested in exploring how tutoring can complement AI and support your student?

Learn more at our Virtual Learning Centre or ask about our EXCEL tutoring memberships.

 
Final Thoughts

AI is changing the classroom, but it can’t replace the connection and coaching that real educators provide. By combining technology with human insight, we can help students get the best of both worlds: innovation and integrity.

Let’s work together to guide this generation of learners—with tools, structure, and the support they deserve.